SpeedyReedy wrote:I can't think of my reasoning for the Beater-STA choice (I think it has to do with how tiring it would be hitting and dodging bludgers for hours on end) but the Seeker-DEX choice, for me, is because I want a Seeker who can get to the snitch. In my estimations, it is the fourth most important skill, but there is no point having 99 DEX if the Seeker loses every head-to-head, or doesn't even notice the snitch or the other Seeker. I'd rather my Seeker win every head to head and eventually grab the snitch, than lose the head to head with 99 DEX simply going to waste.
I have to say I agree with your assessment of Seeker head-to-heads. I value seeker strength above dexterity, although I see now that that isn't clear from my post. I was just ordering my top three in no particular order.
I was more making the point that I think dexterity is more important than agility for seekers, but maybe agility also factors into head-to-heads and I'm not aware?